As with every other team ASM has previewed in this series, the Reds won’t go too far without good pitching. Fortunately for the team, their top two starters are as durable as any in baseball. Unfortunately, the rest of their staff is a series of question marks, one less certain than the next.
Aaron Harang isn’t an ace in the traditional sense, but in a day and age when some teams go an entire season without a complete game, it’s nice to see a #1 like Harang who had 6 in 2006. Couple that with his 16 wins (in 35 starts with a shaky bullpen backing him up), 3.76 ERA and 234.1 innings pitched, and Harang is a workhorse that will keep the Reds in his starts at the very least. Another 16 wins isn’t too much of a reach, but he’ll need to last deep into games to prevent Cincinnati’s shaky bullpen from blowing his leads.
Just as durable as Harang, Bronson Arroyo was rewarded for an excellent 2006 with a three-year contract extension. He posted only a 14-11 but also topped 230 innings pitched (240.2), and had a solid 3.29 ERA. With the rest of the rotation and the bullpen shaky at best, the Reds need Arroyo to match his fast start from ’06 (4-0, 2.34 in April) or they might be buried in the standings before May Day.
The horses at the front of the rotation can ill afford to lose 11 games each again this year, mostly because it’s doubtful the arms behind them will be able to pick up the slack. Fifteen wins might be too much to ask from Eric Milton or Kyle Lohse, but if they can’t even reach that number together as they failed to do last season, the Reds will need to find a lot of wins in a dicey 5th starter slot and a mediocre bullpen.
David Weathers and Mike Stanton’s best years are behind them, Gary Majewski struggled after coming over from Washington in the Austin Kearns deal last summer, and Rheal Cormier saw his ERA nearly triple after arriving from the Phillies. Doesn’t exactly instill a lot of confidence if you’re Jerry Narron and your starter is tiring.
Depending on who you talk to, Homer Bailey is either the best pitching prospect in baseball or the second best. Either way, with a staff like the Reds have, the club's plan to let Bailey marinate in Triple-A for a while might go out the window before April is out. And even if Bailey comes up and is better than advertised, he still won't be able to take the ball more than once every five days, so unless he's the next Clemens from Day One of his big-league career, he won't be able to salvage this staff.
Unfortunately for the Reds, a potent lineup won’t be enough to save them from a last-place finish in a division where the Cards are the defending champs, the Cubs retooled with $317 million worth of warm bodies, the Brewers are a year more experienced, the Astros picked up Carlos Lee and Jason Jennings, and the Pirates are building off an encouraging second half last season.
Playing right field may be all right with Griffey, but things are going to go all wrong for the Reds in 2007.
2006: 80-82 (3rd in NL Central)